MOBILE PHONE USERS LACK LOYALTY BUT RELY HEAVILY ON SERVICES
Watch Out Carriers, Expect More Vocal and Visible Complaints From Consumers Mad About Bad Experiences, Hidden Fees, and Poor Service Quality, Reports CMO Council
Palo Alto, Calif. (August 30, 2012)— The world’s 6.5 billion mobile phone subscribers are likely to become vocal and active detractors if they have a negative customer experience, reveals a new global study by the Chief Marketing Officer (CMO) Council.
Only 34 percent of 1,660 mobile subscribers surveyed around the globe in the second quarter of 2012 are loyal to their carriers and have stayed with their current communications service provider for more than five years. And this loyalty is increasingly being called into question, as customers grow frustrated with more fees, intermittent quality of service, lack of carrier respect, and the frustration of trying to figure out all the options and features of increasingly complex plans.
According to the Ricoh-sponsored study, dubbed “What’s Critical in the Telecommunications Vertical,” 41 percent of mobile phone subscribers say they will lodge a complaint about a poor experience, 36 percent will cancel their service, and 29 percent will tell everyone they know about the incident.
Only 29 percent of those polled across all age groups characterized themselves as loyalists. In contrast, a total of 41 percent of respondents said they were either apathetic, on the fence, or just about gone when it comes to the relationship with their mobile service operator.
What’s triggering the switching and churn among mobile phone subscribers? Not surprisingly, high service plan costs contributed to 48 percent of departures, a better deal with more all-inclusive options seduced 26 percent of defectors, and poor quality of service, such as dropped calls or bad reception, eroded another 23 percent of subscribers.
“Consumers are seeking fast, reliable, and predictable access to services and experiences they initiate using their mobile devices,” noted Liz Miller, Vice President of Marketing Programs for the CMO Council, which represents 6,000 senior marketers controlling some $300 billion in aggregated annual spend. “While they can’t live without their mobile devices, they certainly aren’t hesitant to vocalize their dissatisfactions and express their freedom of choice in selecting another service provider.”
The CMO Council mobile subscriber survey revealed:
- Hidden fees (21 percent), bad service or network speed (17 percent), and high data or text costs (17 percent) topped the list of complaints.
- A surprising 56 percent of respondents fail to see equitable value to cost or are unsure of the fees they pay in proportion to the service they receive.
- Few consumers expressed concerns over a lack of online access (6 percent) or paperless billing (3 percent).
- Consumers are mostly using their phones for calling (84 percent), texting (73 percent), taking photos (48 percent), and going online (39 percent).
- Service providers seems to be leaving money on the table, as 41 percent of consumers had issues regarding how well they were notified or informed about other products or services.
- While 36 percent of consumers say they will cancel their service after a negative experience, 29 percent believe their carriers simply won’t care about their defection.
“Function fatigue and feature frustration once summed up the global consumer’s experience with complex, over-engineered mobile devices; now this has become the consumer mindset about their overly complex plans and online account management interface,” added Miller. “Consumers are looking for assurance that their longstanding loyalty will be repaid with service and relevant communications instead of paying high fees to receive enhanced web services.”
As part of its joint study with Ricoh, the CMO Council also surveyed 147 marketers at communications service providers (CSPs) worldwide. Most appear to be focused on better segmenting, targeting, communicating, and delivering service to their customers. There is a keen awareness among those surveyed for the report that their subscribers want lower-fee plans with higher-touch, personalized service, yet a majority of marketers in these organizations still feel that technology innovation and advancement will satisfy subscribers and grow loyalty. Ironically, only 13 percent of consumers described themselves as technology fiends, eagerly awaiting new innovations to secure their loyalty.
Among the top subscriber engagement priorities for CSP marketers are:
- Retaining their most valuable customers and driving loyalty (47 percent)
- Improving the relevance of communications (40 percent)
- Developing new points of engagement (38 percent)
- Educating customers through relevant content (33 percent)
But age-old issues around data, insights, and functional silos that block access to critical customer insights are challenging marketers looking to execute more relevant, targeted precision marketing campaigns. A surprising 65 percent of marketers admit they are not at all confident in their knowledge of the customer. More than half believe they need better access to real-time analytics to improve their customer lifetime value profiles. Interestingly, 54 percent indicate that tighter alignment of front-line resources is also needed.
“Mobile communications service providers do not lack data,” commented George Promis, Vice President of Continuous Forms Production Solutions & Technology Alliances, Ricoh. “In fact, mobile carriers likely have more customer data than they might realize—all of which can and should be leveraged to create more revenue streams and increase customer loyalty. Without this data, executing the relevant exchanges that consumers are demanding is nearly impossible. Moreover, access to this invaluable data presents telco marketers with a tremendous opportunity to retain highly loyal and enthusiastic customers who admit they are hooked on mobile. It will be the marketer’s game to lose.”
The 32-page report, available for complimentary download at (www.cmocouncil.org/critical-in-the-vertical-telco), includes data gathered from 1,660-plus global consumers and 147 senior marketers. The “What’s Critical in the Vertical” campaign is a series of ongoing reports chronicling the needs, wants, and desires of consumers and how vertical industry marketers’ intentions and strategies plan to drive loyalty and profitability. Previous industries covered in this series include commercial banking (globally and in Australia), insurance, and utilities. To view these reports, visit www.precisionpromotion.com.
About the CMO Council
The Chief Marketing Officer (CMO) Council is dedicated to high-level knowledge exchange, thought leadership, and personal relationship building among senior corporate marketing leaders and brand decision-makers across a wide range of global industries. The CMO Council's 6,000 members control more than $300 billion in aggregated annual marketing expenditures and run complex, distributed marketing and sales operations worldwide. In total, the CMO Council and its strategic interest communities include more than 20,000 global executives in nearly 100 countries covering multiple industries, segments, and markets. Regional chapters and advisory boards are active in the Americas, Europe, Asia-Pacific, Middle East, and Africa. The council's strategic interest groups include the Coalition to Leverage and Optimize Sales Effectiveness (CLOSE), LoyaltyLeaders.org, Marketing Supply Chain Institute, Customer Experience Board, Market Sense-Ability Center, Digital Marketing Performance Institute, GeoBranding Center, and the Forum to Advance the Mobile Experience (FAME). More information about the CMO Council is available at www.cmocouncil.org.
Ricoh is a global technology company specializing in office imaging equipment, production print solutions, document management systems, and IT services. Headquartered in Tokyo, Ricoh Group operates in more than 200 countries and regions. In the financial year ending March 2012, Ricoh Group had worldwide sales of 1,903 billion yen (approximately $23 billion USD). The majority of the company's revenue comes from products, solutions, and services that improve the interaction between people and information. Ricoh also produces award-winning digital cameras and specialized industrial products. It is known for the quality of its technology, the exceptional standard of its customer service, and sustainability initiatives. Under its corporate tagline, "imagine. change." Ricoh helps companies transform the way they work and harness the collective imagination of their employees. For further information, please visit www.ricoh.com/about/.
Ricoh has also established a global leadership role in precision marketing services, which are dedicated to delivering the right message to the right person at the right time via the right channels. This data-driven marketing approach produces highly targeted and relevant customer communications, resulting in improved ROI. Ricoh works with the world's leading brands in the retail, financial services, insurance, banking, travel, and hospitality industries to deliver these solutions and services. Precision marketing offerings provided include customer strategy, retention data analytics, campaign design and delivery, and campaign management services. More information is available at www.infoprint.com/precisionmarketing and www.precisionmarketingbook.com.